UK Religious
Education Policies Violate Human Rights, Critics Say
Since 06-04-08
http://www.cnsnews.com/ViewCulture.asp?Page=/Culture/archive/200806/CUL20080604b.html
London (CNSNews.com) - Charging that the human
rights of teenagers are being violated, lawmakers and humanists are calling
for religious education to be scaled back in British schools.
Christianity is the official state religion in the United Kingdom, and
students in most public schools are required to take religious education
classes and participate in acts of collective worship.
"Such acts must be predominantly Christian in nature over the course of the
year and might include opportunities for prayer and mediation, or assemblies
with a religious theme. Schools with a majority of students who are of other
faiths can apply for an exception to this rule.
Government surveys have found that a number of schools in England have
neglected daily worship, but the requirement remains a sore point for many
humanists.
Francis Farrell, an expert on religious education at Edge Hill University in
northwest England, said religious education classes usually deal with the
study of Christianity and at least two other world religions in a given
year.
Parents are allowed to keep their children out of religious education and
daily worship, and since 2006, pupils in their final year of school also
have been allowed to choose not to participate in worship.
Last month, a parliamentary human rights committee issued a report
recommending that students below the age of 16 also be allowed to opt out of
religious education classes and daily worship as long as they have
"sufficient maturity, intelligence and understanding."
The lawmakers said forcing a student to engage in these activities was
"incompatible" with the child's freedom of thought, conscience and belief.
It also violated the European Convention on Human Rights, the report said.
The National Secular Society says it is often approached by parents
"outraged" that their children were "effectively forced to worship."
Executive director Keith Porteous Wood said in a statement the society would
consider legal action if the government continued to make children to act
against their values.
"This would not be tolerated in any other context," he said. "We will look
out for a suitable case of a pupil mature enough to make their own decision
and consider challenging the government on the issue."
A spokeswoman for the Department for Children, Schools and Families said
there were no plans to change the current rules and declined to comment on
any possible lawsuit.
The report by the parliamentary committee came shortly after Cardinal Cormac
Murphy-O'Connor, head of the Catholic Church in England and Wales, warned
that Britain was in danger of becoming a "God-free zone."
In a lecture in London, Murphy-O'Connor said atheists were wrong in claiming
that unreason lay behind a belief in God.
For believers, he said, faith was the flowering of reason.
"One of the things which I challenge is the desire to separate Christianity
from rational inquiry," he said. "Many of our 'new atheists' seem unable to
cope with the notion of an intelligent, reflective Christian faith."
In another development, the British Humanist Association (BHA) recently
secured two places on a 30-member advisory committee that will meet over the
next 18 months and eventually recommend to the government changes to
religious education guidelines.
Membership in the committee is drawn from a wide range of faiths and groups
involved in religious education.
Andrew Copson, the BHA's director of education and public affairs, said
existing guidelines placed an undue emphasis on Christianity and was
"seriously out of step" with what he said was contemporary best practice in
teaching about religions and non-religious beliefs.
With church attendance in Britain dramatically dropping in the last decade,
it was ridiculous that most children spend more time in religious observance
than their parents, he said.